Listen to Legacy Lore
Season One: The Accused, a seven-episode, is an immersive narrative investigation into a 17th-century witchcraft accusation drawn from court records, land deeds, and surviving colonial documents.
The season grew out of more than a decade of genealogical research, when host Sammy Jo uncovered an unsettling truth about her 11th great-grandmother, Eleanor Neale, a woman whose accusation echoed a larger pattern seen across history.
Through Eleanor’s case, Legacy Lore reconstructs how fear, rumor, and power operated within early legal systems, and how those forces were often wielded by powerful men to silence women and enforce compliance. What begins as one family’s discovery becomes a broader examination of accusation, survival, and the enduring consequences of fear-driven justice.
Season Two: Sea Witches, follows the cases of Katherine Grady and Elizabeth Richardson, two women accused of witchcraft before their ships ever reached land. Their stories emerge from fragmented maritime records in 1654 and 1658 - accounts not of investigation, but of authority.
Discovered in the course of researching Eleanor Neale’s case, their accusations initially appeared as brief entries in colonial records. But closer examination reveals something deeper: not a question of guilt or innocence, but of who had the power to judge.
Aboard two different ships, bound for two different colonies, Katherine Grady and Elizabeth Richardson experienced strikingly similar fates. In both cases, the records do not ask whether a crime had been committed. Instead, they ask who held the legal authority to carry out punishment in the uncertain space between sea and shore.
Through these parallel stories, Legacy Lore examines how maritime law operated in the mid-17th century, and how jurisdiction blurred when distance separated individuals from formal courts.
Step inside the archive on Patreon